UnitedHealth, CVS, Centene to lose Medicare star bonuses for 2023

For some firms, it is not the quantity of plans that acquired a extreme rating that is important, nonetheless the scale of the plans’ membership. 

almost 38% of Aetna’s insurance coverage policies acquired no decrease than 4 stars, down from fifty five.6%. however rankings for the CVS well being subsidiary’s largest plan, the Aetna nationwide PPO, fell to three.5 stars, dropping the product under the 4-star bonus threshold. greater than 1.9 million people are enrolled inside the Aetna nationwide PPO, which represents fifty nine% of the agency’s Medicare benefit membership. 

Aetna attributed the decline to poor scores inside the patron evaluation of Healthcare suppliers and functions survey (CAHPS). the agency recognized the scarcity of stars income as a headwind for 2024 earnings and plans to mitigate a pair of of the draw again by means of “ongoing contract diversification efforts,” in accordance with a Securities and change fee submitting submitted Wednesday. 

“This 12 months rankings declined commerce large,” an Aetna spokesperson wrote in an e mail. “CMS elevated reliance on member surveys to at least one third of the full Star rating. With our largest nationwide PPO contract’s outcomes based mostly on decrease than 1,000 member survey responses out of almost 2 million members – decrease than one-tenth of 1% – we don’t think about they precisely mirror the full expertise of our Medicare benefit members.”

medical well being insurance coverage commerce affiliation AHIP attributed the commerce-large declines to the persevering with COVID-19 pandemic, as properly as to to CMS modifying the most interesting means it calculated rankings this 12 months. CMS made a quantity of adjustments, resembling doubling the burden that CAHPS scores have on star rankings.

CMS additionally assessed Medicare benefit plans using its pre-pandemic requirements. The agency relaxed the most interesting means it calculated Medicare benefit star rankings for 2021 and 2022 as an component of COVID-19 discount, which led a report quantity of insurers to garner extreme scores and a corresponding enhance in federal spending on bonuses. 

“we look forward to partaking with CMS to deal with methodological and fully different factors to make sure that there are appropriate, reliable indicators of plan efficiency,” AHIP President and CEO Matt Eyles mentioned in a press launch. 

the overwhelming majority of Medicare benefit members stay enrolled in extreme-performing plans, Eyles mentioned. roughly seventy two% of all Medicare benefit members with half D advantages are coated by plans that scored no decrease than 4 stars, in accordance with CMS. 

Fifty-seven Medicare benefit plans with prescription drug safety earned 5 out of 5 stars, a decline from seventy 4 in 2022, CMS mentioned. Plans with a 5-star rating are allowed to market their product all 12 months, giving them a leg up on opponents that are restricted to promoting  merchandise all by means of the six-week open enrollment interval.

amongst for-revenue insurers, Humana expert the smallest change, with greater than seventy three% of its forty one plans receiving no decrease than 4 stars, down from seventy eight%. Ninety-six % of Humana Medicare benefit members are presently enrolled in plans rated 4 stars and above for 2023, a spokesperson wrote in an e mail.

all of the seven plans operated by Kaiser basis well being Plan acquired no decrease than 4 stars, representing no 12 months-over-12 months change. Not-for-revenue insurers tended to discover greater than for-revenue firms inside the celebs program, CMS mentioned. 

Tim Broderick contributed to this story.