R. Kelly’s lead legal professional instructed jurors all by her closing argument Tuesday that federal prosecutors’ case accusing the singer of producing youngster pornography, engaging minors for intercourse and rigging his 2008 youngster porn trial largely rests on the testimony of perjurers and blackmailers.
Standing at a podium a quantity of ft in entrance of jurors, Jennifer Bonjean famous that many key authorities witnesses, collectively with amongst the numerous ladies who accused Kelly of sexually abusing them, testified with immunity to make constructive that they’d not be charged with beforehand mendacity to authorities.
Bonjean mentioned they hadn’t come to the courthouse in Chicago, Kelly’s hometown, to inform the unvarnished actuality. “They obtained here in right here,” she mentioned, “to inform the federal authorities’s mannequin of the exact actuality.”
amongst others, she cited Kelly ex-girlfriend Lisa Van Allen, who testified about how she stole a intercourse tape from a Kelly health coronary heart bag inside the early 2000s. Bonjean additionally pointed to the testimony of Kelly’s former merchandising agent Charles Freeman, who instructed jurors that he requested the singer for $1 million US in change for returning one other intercourse tape that would probably incriminate the singer. each testified with immunity.
WATCH | R. Kelly’s lawyer says singer will face ‘tainted’ jury:
Bonjean likened their testimony and completely different proof to a cockroach and the federal authorities’s case to a bowl of soup the insect is current in.
“you do not simply pull out the cockroach and eat the the rest of the soup,” she mentioned, noting of the prosecution’s case: “There are simply too many cockroaches.”
Bonjean reminded jurors that she instructed them all by her opening assertion that the federal authorities would rely on “perjurers, blackmailers and extortionists,” and mentioned prosecutors had carried out simply that.
Singer used fame to regulate, argues prosecutor
On Monday, a prosecutor in her closing instructed jurors that weeks of proof proved the singer parlayed his fame to sexually abuse minors and report the abuse on video.
Kelly faces costs collectively with manufacturing of youngster pornography, engaging minor ladies for intercourse and obstruction of justice by rigging his 2008 youngster pornography trial in state court docket, at which he was acquitted. Jurors have been anticipated to started deliberating later Tuesday.
In her closing, prosecutor Elizabeth Pozolo described Kelly as a secret sexual predator.
“Robert Kelly abused many ladies over a few years,” she mentioned, referring to the fifty five-yr-outdated by his full first title. “He dedicated horrible crimes in opposition to kids…. All these years later, the hidden side of Robert Kelly has come out.”
Bonjean twice recognized as for a mistrial on Monday, complaining that closing arguments by legal professionals for Kelly co-defendants Derrell McDavid and Milton Brown have been grounded inside the presumption that “the world now is aware of Mr. Kelly is a intercourse predator.”
“The presumption of innocence has been abolished for him,” Bonjean mentioned, which means Kelly was unable to get a very good trial. decide Harry Leinenweber denied the requests.
Prosecutors can have the likelihood for a quick rebuttal after Bonjean affords her closing argument in Kelly’s hometown of Chicago, the place he rose from poverty to develop to be an R&B superstar.
recognized for his smash hit I think about I Can Fly and for intercourse-infused songs reminiscent of Bump n’ Grind, Kelly supplied hundreds and hundreds of albums even after allegations of sexual misconduct started circulating inside the Nineties. Widespread outrage emerged after the #MeToo reckoning and the 2019 docuseries Surviving R. Kelly.
Kelly and McDavid, Kelly’s former enterprise supervisor, are accused of fixing the 2008 trial by intimidating and paying off witnesses. each face youngster pornography costs. Brown, a former Kelly affiliate, is accused of receiving youngster pornography.
Trial may add years to Kelly’s current sentence
Kelly was sentenced in June to 30 years in jail after a separate federal trial in the ny, the place he was convicted of racketeering and intercourse trafficking. Convictions on solely a quantity of of the thirteen counts Kelly faces at his current trial may add years to his imprisonment.
Pozolo centered a lot of her closing argument on the federal authorities’s star witness, an accuser who glided by “Jane” and who mentioned Kelly sexually abused her tons of of instances starting when she was 14.
“He carried out degrading acts upon her for his personal sick pleasure,” Pozolo mentioned.
She reminded jurors of graphic video footage that they had watched, which Jane testified depicted Kelly, at round age 30, abusing her when she was 14. The movies proven included one on the center of Kelly’s 2008 trial. Jurors mentioned later that they had no selection however to acquit Kelly as a consequence of Jane did not testify.
“Who does that? Who makes use of a 14-yr-outdated youngster to film a video like this?” she mentioned. “This man. Robert Kelly.”
WATCH | R&B singer R. Kelly receives 30-yr jail sentence:
earlier than Kelly’s 2008 trial, Pozolo mentioned, Kelly and his associates scrambled to recuperate a quantity of intercourse movies that had gone lacking from a set he typically carried round in a large health coronary heart bag.
By doing so, she mentioned, Kelly associates sought “to cowl up the exact indisputable actuality that … R. Kelly, the R&B superstar, is unquestionably a sexual predator.”
In his closing, a lawyer for McDavid mentioned prosecutors needed to level out that his consumer actually knew about any abuse of Jane by Kelly inside the 2000s — not simply that it was seemingly he knew.
“Did they show he knew … beyong an affordable doubt?” Beau Brindley requested. “they did not.”
Pozolo balked on the idea McDavid had no inkling inside the 2000s that the abuse allegations is in all probability credible after serving to to recuperate lacking recordings and handing luggage of money to people who returned movies McDavid knew may destroy Kelly.